Friday, November 29, 2019

MY DOVE-ORCE -- I left peace group activism. Peace was fine. Groupthink wasn't.

Protests were common in Louisville in the '90s
 and 2000s, and FORsooth documented them.
EDDIE DAVIS photo

Reconciling enemies was so central to our group’s identity that it was in our name. And in 1991, as editor of the monthly newspaper of the Louisville chapter of the Fellowship of Reconciliation, I relished the role of defying the dominant paradigm that had the mainstream of the United States welled up with intoxicating jingoism over a six-week military triumph. The Iraq we had beaten in the Persian Gulf War had been presented to the American people as their enemy for only five months, following 21 years of unquestioned backing of Saddam Hussein after he took power in 1969.


Alone among area media, our paper FORsooth (which means “in truth,” flowing from the group’s acronym) smashed the icon of American triumph, telling our community that we had not beaten Iraq in any war to stop aggression – we had returned to the throne an autocratic Kuwaiti royal family to keep our petrodollar economy afloat.


Using as sources University of Louisville engineering professor and Palestinian state activist Ibrahim Imam, civil rights radical Jack O’Dell, and American House of Saud author Steven Emerson, FORsooth introduced our readership to the concept of petrodollars.


No, the Persian Gulf War wasn’t really a “war for oil” but a “war for petrodollars.” We waged it to keep America’s dysfunctional fiscal mess artificially capable of coexisting with economic growth. Reaganomics was a fraud; his tripling of the yearly deficits would have sent the nation into depression were it not for the Persian Gulf oil state family dictatorships buying massive amounts of U.S. currency.


Brian Arbenz distributes FORsooth
 in West Louisville, where he tried to
persuade more peace activists to go.
His byline was George Morrison,
which was his legal  name in those days.

This unearned fiscal influx kept the U.S. from collapsing in its own ‘80s red ink. Moreover, the American and British economies were dependent on the family-run governments of Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, United Arab Emirates, Qatar, and Yemen spending billions and billions of the profits from their 51 percent state-owned oil companies on infrastructure made by U.K and U.S. corporations, most notably Bechtel and Parsons. Both these flows of oil money back to us were known as “petrodollars.”


FORsooth eagerly said that the war was a horrible consequence of this fiscal neediness by the United States, not a shining example of our military responsiveness against aggression. We noted that when Indonesia brutally overran East Timor in 1975 and when West Pakistan rapaciously crushed the Bangladeshi independence movement in 1971, the State Department sided with the Saddam Hussein equivalents in those episodes.


Members of our Fellowship of Reconciliation chapter spoke in forums and debates at high schools and colleges, and though we were usually received favorably, one couple (the husband was a prominent criminal court judge) called us on the phone and both shouted denunciations of FORsooth writings about the war. In a TV exchange over the issue, a not yet nationally known Senator Mitch McConnell called a speaker from our FOR chapter “part of that blame America crowd.”

A Louisville woman blocks the Persian Gulf "victory parade," and in New York City, Ramsey Clark documents
 civilian deaths. FORsooth was there for both. 

What’s the matter, many in the general public asked. Can’t these peace activists see that this war was a totally good cause against a unilateral aggressor? Never mind that the U.S. had long given weapons to the side we were suddenly fighting. Don’t bother us with the fact that Kuwait had for years refused Iraqi demands that it stop illegally taking oil from oilfields under Iraq. And forget that Ivy League stuff about these petrodollars you say exist. We want to see this as simply good versus evil. Because we want that “Vietnam Syndrome” lifted!


Persian Gulf War passions soon faded, but our advocacy’s fervor didn’t. We kept denouncing unfair and fatal sanctions against Iraqis, kept calling for the establishment of a Palestinian state, backed LGBT rights and Affirmative Action, and kept demanding the end of U.S-created death squads in Latin America and the embargo against Cuba.

FORsooth frequently examined
Restorative Justice, which
corporate media overlooked.

And as I look over archived issues, it is striking that FORsooth – counter to corporate media cheeriness about the rational marketplace, the logical U.S. foreign policy and the post-racial America -- ran prescient pieces warning of soaring housing foreclosures, the specter of fascism behind the anti-Affirmative Action movement, and the unsustainability of American military power.


Renowned FOR activist John Swomley in 1998 foresaw precisely our
situation today

As the years went by, planes went into the World Trade Towers, our military went into Iraq, and the FOR and its paper FORsooth remained steadfast and unafraid to challenge all the dominant paradigms.


I decided to step down as editor in 2011 and cut back to part time work writing and helping a new crew do the publishing. After 21 years, I needed to slow down from a demanding if personally fulfilling regimen of researching, writing, opining, editing, driving 60 miles each issue to and from the printing plant, and then distributing the monthly FORsooth around parts of Louisville and Southern Indiana – all while working other full time jobs.



I absolutely loved doing all this, yet I also gained contentment of a different sort from stepping down. I had more time for unstructured, spontaneous face-in-the-crowd activism. Everyone was expressing appreciation in person and in letters to the editor for my decades of work. More than once, a stranger recognizing me in a sidewalk encounter praised my work and mourned my decision to retire. The chapter paid me a cash gratuity that was larger than I expected or deserved. Everything was harmonious. The future was bright.


Four years later, I left the Fellowship of Reconciliation. My long and deep association with FORsooth ceased. A planned stint on an FOR community radio station never happened. I have discontinued working with all the peace groups of which Louisville’s FOR chapter served as a sort of umbrella, groups with names like Interfaith Paths to Peace and the Council on Peacemaking.


Peace organizations are problematic. The peace part is fine. It’s the organization that is often the problem.


The veneer of my compatibility with group activism here began to crack in 2015 when I published a thoroughly documented column that examined the Middle East conflict as more than just a unilateral struggle for a Palestinian homeland. To be sure, I made it clear their nation deserved a homeland as much as Israelis did and that I firmly grasped that Israel’s settlements in the occupied territory were illegal. I said that the U.S. in the '70s should have made aid to Israel contingent on the settlements being removed.


But specifics in my column and the sidebar I published about petrodollars drew the ire of the Louisville FOR steering committee. As I see it, the groupthink was disturbed by things I wrote.


To summarize, my column and sidebar said:

*The $185 billion in U.S. aid to Israel since 1948 needs to be seen in the context of the whole story of the U.S. checkbook in the Mideast and Southwest Asia. Since '48, the United States has given $114 billion in aid to Egypt, $59 billion to Iraq and $52 billion in aid to Pakistan. Whereas Israel’s practices of demolition of Palestinian houses, onerous checkpoints and illegal settlements have been bad, Egypt, Pakistan and Iraq also have histories of awful human rights abuses against minorities.


*There is much more to our monetary aid to the Mideast than federal budget outlays. Persian Gulf petrodollar lobbies funded by our gasoline purchases have wielded power comparable to the Israeli lobby (the AWACS plane deal, U.S. militarizing of the Gulf, and even businesses which were seeking deals with Saudi Arabia pressuring South Carolina’s PBS affiliate into blocking a Frontline report on Saudi human rights practices).


*The much described apartheid is present only in the occupied territories, not all of Israel, and a Boycott-Divestment-Sanctions strategy should be more precisely focused on that occupation, not all of Israel. That makes sense – we’re out to end Israel’s bad policies, not its existence. And we can win the wide circle of supporters like we did with South African divestment if we make this distinction.


*My conclusion: peace activists need to look at reversing the arming of all sides, instead of focusing only on our arming of Israel. The excessive militarization of the Middle East overall is the chief hindrance to a Palestinian homeland and Middle East peace. As part of this, we need to face facts about Hamas’ continuing call for Israel’s destruction, while we keep fighting against Israel’s destruction of the Palestinians.

I fully agree, but alternative ideas for a strategy were not welcome.
EDDIE DAVIS photo

My piece seemed to echo those 1991 unorthodox positions that the Persian Gulf war was not plainly a crusade for good versus evil, but maintenance of a web of addictions. I was applying the same principles to this greater Mideast war.


Looking at how both sides are implicated in a conflict is the very life blood of reconciliation. But the Fellowship of Reconciliation wasn’t having it.

What I called for in my column went against a national FOR position, I was told during a meeting.


First of all, I responded, I don’t see any FOR position unambiguously clashing with what I wrote (A national FOR leader had said in a Louisville talk we covered that violence by both sides in the Mideast hampered peace efforts).

Secondly, so what if there is a clash? FORsooth had published pieces from area activists expressing views conflicting with national FOR positions on such matters as the Cuba’s human rights record and U.S. reparations for slavery.


I told the FOR chapter they were selectively pulling rank, stifling initiative, and refusing to honestly critique a side we support in a struggle. All of this is what turns good causes into bad ones, I said.


The meeting was civil if frank, and I have continued to get along well with FOR members when I encounter them. It has been an amicable divorce. And for me, a liberating one.


I immediately began to see that my “life partner” the institution of organized peace activism hadn’t been a good fit for me all along. I had been accommodating it by mentally looking the other way over matters I needed to speak up about – yeah, this is sounding just like a divorce, isn’t it?

 

Another defining moment was when I was told by a more experienced colleague, "That's endemic of the peace movement," when I had complained about a poor choice in 1990 by a peace delegation to Iraq -- including FOR members -- trying to head off the Gulf War. The group had assembled for a photograph joining hands around a highly military-themed monument memorializing but also celebrating Iraqi soldiers who had died in the Iran-Iraq War. It seemed to be showing solidarity with that 1980s war effort by Saddam Hussein. Opposing a U.S. war against a government should not equal a value judgement on that government's tactics, a distinction that picture failed to make.


Among issues other than their intolerance of my Mideast views was the matter of Louisville peace groups’ comfort with the privileges brought to them by racism.


I loved being in our city’s black community West Louisville, and I went there often for shopping, eating, hunting down news stories, getting my car serviced. I liked going there just because it is part of my community – as it is, not an afterthought. So did several other people in the FOR and associated groups. 


But the majority of white Louisville FOR members were not very different from whites in the city overall in the extent to which they lived by unexamined segregationist habit. Nationally, the group rested on racial and economic privilege, and not merely to the degree that is inevitable because of the nature of our society.


As time went by, I saw that the unconscious white comfort-zone bonding that underlay peace activism in Louisville was more conscious than I had thought.

After a consortium of groups organized a couple of night vigils against the Iraq War in white, bohemian neighborhoods, two of us suggested by e-mails that the next one be held at the African-American operated Lyles Mall, a shopping and social services center in the heart of black West Louisville.


“We’ll think about that,” was the e-mailed reply. Thinking was all they did (if they even did that). These organizers, whose activism had taken them to El Salvador, Vietnam and Palestine, would not hold a vigil three miles away in their own city’s black community. Some had attended events and rallies in West Louisville, but would they venture there on their own initiative? Would they roam beyond their tribe?


I recall procuring a photographer for a photo shoot at the same Lyles Mall parking lot for a “person in the street” feature I was writing, and again for a story in Shively, a racially mixed working-class suburb bordering West Louisville.

This photographer, who was white and grew up in a peace activist family, had very seldom been to West Louisville, and had never been to Shively. Yet, she had made two youth delegation trips to the Soviet Union.


She was completely happy to do these photo assignments, and moreover, I don’t wish to make lump-sum observations. There were some peace activists in Louisville who traveled to conflict points in the Third World and who had great involvement with and consciousness about the African-American community. There needed to be more, however. And whites here need to go to the black community on a wide basis, and interact with the people there as individuals, not just representations of issues.

EDDIE DAVIS photo

I knew a couple of white peace organizers who told of feeling unwelcome in their first efforts working in black Louisville organizations, and whether or not they realized it they were using these initial bad experiences as excuses to stay with white activism.


There were other incompatibilities between me and the peace groups, including their scant contacts with media that could have made us known much better in the community overall, not just among our genre.


Many activists would insist that through FORsooth, marches, leafleting and letters to the editor, they were reaching out, but FOR organizers did not try to hold a meeting with the Louisville daily newspaper’s editorial board, or to establish a rapport with any reporter. They often would tell the media about an upcoming event with too-short notice.

 

And the superb street protest photography of progressive documentarian Eddie Davis, which he made available to us at-cost, was underappreciated by FOR chapter leaders. His vibrant pics of marches and speakers told the story of an era, but most in the chapter preferred static podium or mug shots.


To address this problem of missed opportunities, I persuaded the FOR to include among its breakout sessions at its 1994 FOR National Conference, which was held in Louisville, one called: “Getting the Word Out -- Using Media,” which I would present.


Of the hundreds of FOR members and other activists attending this conference, two attended that break out session.

Well, three, if you count the man who fell asleep as I was conducting it. Really. This was a rather blunt hint that my idea of what makes good strategy was not shared by the body of the FOR.


I began to think that I -- despite being liked by the people in the Louisville and national FOR – was not really where I belonged.

Too much slumber was anything but the problem for a few other activists in the wider movement. They seemed unable to rest minds that were always alarmed and unable to establish priorities.

Though FOR members overwhelmingly were comfortable with themselves and emotionally mature, in the greater circle of these groups in Louisville, a few people were sectarian absolutists who lacked judiciousness or patience. Some had litmus tests – “If that position is in your platform, I’m walking!” – that keep the left spinning its wheels.


A few of the more fervent activists were mixing their own struggles from past personal troubles with the worldwide struggle. It is fine for people with such problems to be in activism, but sometimes those who worked with them grew tired of seeing meetings, marches and submitted commentaries weighed down by fist-clenching, unnuanced self-assuredness that jet fuel won’t melt steel, and so forth.


I know personal difficulties can’t and shouldn’t be fully separated from our world views, but please - a certain amount of separation is needed to improve our efforts at both.


Within weeks of leaving the realm of organized peace activism, I could see how minimal its impact had been on the wider community here. I could see how even groups and committees populated by good and sensible people were often rendered ineffective by overstressed zealots. And I also became aware of the problem of activists who - though well intentioned - are quasi professionals who are inwardly turned to each other, rather than toward the community.


And those who eagerly go to El Salvador and Russia, but only think of traveling 15 minutes to the west side of their own city.



Brian Arbenz has worked for peace, economic equity and reconciliation for more than 40 years, and will continue to, unencumbered by group politics. 

Sunday, November 17, 2019

Allan Melvin - Always in Character, Often in Uniform

 
Rob Petrie had four old Army pals who were tall, had deep voices and wavy blonde hair.

Three were shown in flashbacks (a Dick Van Dyke Show innovation) and were perhaps the same person – the trio were named Sam Pomerantz, Sam Pomeroy, and Sol Pomerantz, depending on the episode. (The blog Toobworld calls them the "Pom-Poms.")


The fourth, a distinctly different character who visits Rob and Laura's New Rochelle home in the present, was an immaculately dressed, pleasant but mysterious jeweler named Harrison B. Harding.


All four (or both, if the Pom-Poms are to be regarded as one fellow) were played by the same person – the consummate TV character actor Allan Melvin.

Melvin also played a prison guard in a Dick Dan Dyke episode, and in another, a gun salesman in the old west in a dream Rob has (dream sequences were another Van Dyke Show innovation).


To further complicate the Pom-Pom legacy, another actor also played an Army buddy of Rob’s named Sam Pomerantz, proving that no one in the ‘60s foresaw home video or the Internet someday enabling sitcom devotees to quibble.


To clear up which Pom is Allan Melvin, behold his familiar face and voice in this Dick Van Dyke Show link as Sol Pomerantz:




As Sgt. Charlie Hacker on Gomer Pyle USMC:


.
And, in one of a series of Liquid Plumber ads he did in the 1970s and ‘80s:

(as though plumbers wear their uniforms to parties)

Now  you know who Allan Melvin was -- if telling Sam from Sol is still a little tricky. Melvin was born in Kansas City, Mo., the son of a New York City-based distributor of silent films to amusement arcades in the Midwest. A young Allan moved with his family to New York City, where he grew up, then was educated at Columbia University.


Before the Dick Van Dyke or Gomer Pyle series, Melvin donned a military uniform as Army Corporal Steve Henshaw in The Phil Silvers Show in the 1950s. But he wasn’t just a screen serviceman; Melvin joined the Navy during World War II, helping build naval vessels at the Port Newark Shipyard in New Jersey, the website philsilversshow.com said.


But entertainment was Melvin's avocation during the war.

"He learned to do voices and he practiced doing impressions of all kinds of people and things," The Phil Silvers website said. "Some College acting friends, Frank Campanella, Thomas McDermott and a young actress called Amalia Sestero had started a theatrical group, The Unicorn Players. Frank invited Allan to one of their meetings -- the die was cast. Allan and Amalia started dating, fell in love..."

In 1944 Allan John Melvin and Amalia Faustina Sestero wed in New York City.  In a pattern of stability that seems to typify character actors, they stayed married until Allan Melvin died in 2008 at age 84. They had two daughters.


        Allan Melvin's debt to the great Phil Silvers:

 

Before going into television, Melvin did superb voice impressions of legends like James Stewart and Cary Grant while he performed with stage comedy ensembles, and won acclaim for his role in the Broadway play "Stalag 17" as an American POW who amid the misery of the camp entertains co-prisoners using similar talents.


Melvin worked in NBC's sound effects department, creating radio show sounds using devices, recordings and sometimes his own voice.


The forceful yet soothing Allan Melvin vocal style had a career of its own, as he also did cartoon voices of Magilla Gorilla, Sergeant Snorkel, Bumbler, Barney Google and Bristol Hound.


Melvin had a small role in the 1968 Doris Day movie "With Six You Get Eggroll," in which he plays a police sergeant who is confronted by hippies played by future M*A*S*H cast members Jamie Farr and William Christopher (yep, the Father played a hippie)


                       Allan experiences the '60s,

                                                         but he "ain't groovy."

 

Other than being in that oddly cast scene, Melvin's on-screen work was entirely through television, unlike character actor icons such as Edward Andrews, Reta Shaw and Whit Bissell, who also intermittently acted in movies. That made Allan Melvin probably the top "Household Face," if not name, in TV.


And every generation of TV viewers has its Allan Melvin peg. For some, it’s Henshaw or Charlie Hacker. Seventies kids knew him as Sam the butcher, Alice’s love interest on The Brady Bunch. There was also Barney Hefner, the Bunkers’ neighbor on All in the Family who was just as blue-collar as Archie, but never expressed bigotry.


Published obituaries of Allan in 2008 tended to reveal the generation of the writer based on which of those characters he was described as "best known for playing."


In several of the obits, Amalia Sestero Melvin said her husband's favorite role had been in The Phil Silvers Show. "I think the camaraderie of all those guys made it such a pleasant way to work. They were so relaxed," said Amalia, who lived to age 100, dying in December 2020.


Just as with playing the rotating Army buddy of Rob, Melvin pulled off a switcheroo on All in the Family, too.

Before being the semi-regular Barney Hefner, he appeared as New York City police officer Pulaski in an episode’s final scene where Archie gets his comeuppance for his characteristic use of an anti-Polish slur:

 

One of the foundations of the character actor profession -- the subliminal semi-recognition viewers have of them – is what enabled Melvin to play two people in one program.


"I went in the same season from Pulaski to Barney Hefner. I think they make allowances for the fact that the audience will accept certain changes,” Melvin said in an early 1970s interview. “I guess they figure since it was a one-shot, I wasn't that established. I've been Barney ever since." This was from a British blog on Phil Silvers Show stars; that great 1950s military comedy had Melvin in the cast as Henshaw, an army cohort of the irrepressible Sgt. Ernie Bilko.


Melvin was recalled to duty as Marine Sergeant Charlie Hacker on Gomer Pyle USMC during the same decade he played the Army "Pom-Poms."


If playing two characters each in New Rochelle and Astoria, N.Y. was a task, Allan Melvin’s work in Mayberry, N.C, was a high-wire juggling act.


On The Andy Griffith Show, he played eight different people, reported the web site fans-pages.com, which labeled Melvin’s constant work on the show: “Mayberry’s Multiple Personality Disorder.”


Among his Andy Griffith Show roles were a jailed suspect whom Barney tries to trick into giving evidence, a roadside vendor who disses the deputy only to learn what authority really means, and a recruiting sergeant who struggles with the not-exactly G.I Ernest T. Bass.


In another roughneck role, Melvin played local bully Fred Plummer, who bedevils Deputy Fife. Barney is impersonated by his judo instructor who overpowers Plummer into respect for the undersized deputy he thinks has clobbered him.


Switching to the right side of the law, Melvin played an eagle-eyed hotel detective in an Andy Griffith Show episode in which Andy and Barney make an out-of-town trip.


Melvin described nearly every TV show he was in as fun more so than work. He regularly praised the entertainment stars he worked with, including Phil Silvers, Frank Sutton, Andy Griffith, and producer Aaron Ruben.


Particularly satisfying to Allan Melvin was the Dick Van Dyke Show:

"It was marvelous, exhilarating," he said. "It was so well written and conceived and the working conditions were so great, working with Carl Reiner and Dick and Mary and the whole crowd. And it was just a joy because it was a very creative show. It was an early kind of a watershed ensemble comedy show."

Those words were posted on Philsilversshow.com, on which Melvin also fondly recalled The Phil Silvers Show -- originally called "You'll Never Get Rich," and also often referred to as "Bilko" -- for timeless TV quality.

"A Bilko show could be funny 50 years from now. Funny is funny. It's as simple as that."

 
            __________________________________________

  

Brian Arbenz, of Louisville, Ky. USA, has throughout his life loved watching Sams, Sols, Plumbers and Plummers, Marines and Soldiers, Barney adversaries and Barney Hefners named Allan Melvin.

 

And for a closing act, a few minutes of a rare suit-and-tie clad civilian Allan Melvin as the mysterious old friend (or crook?) Harrison B. Harding:


              --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For even more on Allan Melvin, CLICK HERE to go to KJ Ricardo's YouTube
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Saturday, October 19, 2019

Are You a Whit Spotter? Viewers of TV and movies from the 1950s through the '70s probably are

An ambassador in Star Trek’s “The Trouble with Tribbles,” the technocrat who ran The Time Tunnel, a conniving U.S. senator in the tense political movie, “7 Days in May” – all these screen roles highlighted the tightly wired officiousness yet lilting voice that were hallmarks of the man who played them.

Whit Bissell was one of the most prolific character actors, those performers you recognize, yet don’t. Bissell preferred the term “supporting player,” to “character actor,” but either way, he excelled at projecting his own mellow and soothing qualities into a scene, then practicing that courtesy of a supporting player/character actor by bowing out to let the big stars, or younger hot-shots do the iconic parts that made their names household words.

But then if you were born Whitner Nutting Bissell, vocal and facial gifts, rather than your name, likely would be your performing strengths.


An awkward moniker and intense administrator roles belie Whit Bissell’s real-life relaxed, charming and well-read nature. Still, friend Bernie Shine wrote on Leonard Maltin’s entertainment web site that it took some tenacity by Bissell, the son of a New York City physician, to break into the business.

"He told me that when he was starting out he found himself on the opposite side of the desk of a famous Hollywood mogul who bluntly told him that he didn’t have what it takes to be a leading man, stating, ‘I don’t see any women burning with desire when they see you,’ “ Shine wrote. “Whit responded, ‘Perhaps not, but I do think I could make them feel other emotions, such as laughing, crying, or caring.’ ”

Indeed, character actors may be told early in their careers they don’t have the sizzle or the physical stature to be heartthrobs or heroes. But after years of frequent, often brief appearances, the masterful facial skills and appealing voices of the most successful make them recognized, or even craved.

A character actor’s constant moving from one production to another to play unrelated roles makes casting and filming for TV and movies less costly, and it makes the actor something of a rolling stone.

But they can gather the moss of recognition if they achieve long professional life. Many character actors, or supporting players, have sub-cultures of close followers and appreciation of their skills has grown due to the Internet.

A commenter on Silverscreenoasis.com said of Bissell:

“I've often thought of Whit as something of a second-tier Hume Cronyn. I've always liked his speaking voice, which I think very rich, mellow, and distinctive.”

                      2 scenes of Whit in charge of "The Time Tunnel," 1966:




  

A certain studious air helped land the bespectacled Bissell parts as scientists in many of the best sci-fi movies of the 1950s through the early ‘70s, including “I was a Teenage Frankenstein,” “Soylent Green,” “I was a Teenage Werewolf,” and “Creature from the Black Lagoon.” He also had roles in “The Magnificent Seven” and “Pete ‘n’ Tillie,” and appeared in such stalwart TV series as McCloud, Land of the Giants, Here’s Lucy, Gomer Pyle: USMC, Kojak, Cannon, Marcus Welby, M.D. and Ben Casey, generally playing trusted figures like doctors, chaplains and professors.


                                 On the witness stand in The Cain Mutiny, 1954:






Another post on Silverscreenoasis.com said Whit's first name has become a synonym for the supporting player genre to which he devoted his life:

“ ‘Character actor' isn't a good enough term to describe Whit’s talents, so, for many years now, I have referred to any reliable character actor that happens to pop up as a ‘Whit.’ It’s an honorific term, meant to notice and celebrate his and other actors' contributions as support in countless films…. One of the pleasures of watching TV with friends in the 70s was to do ‘Whit-spotting’ and point him out to others. 'Oh yeah! I've seen that guy before!' was the usual response.”

                                              __________________________

Brian Arbenz of Louisville, Ky. USA has been spotting Whit all his life, but has been aware of it only since becoming fascinated with the movie "7 Days in May" in the 1990s. 

 

Bonus footage: Whit Bissell in a 1965 Profiles in Courage re-enactment of President Woodrow Wilson appointing Louis Brandeis to the U.S. Supreme Court. It's rather high school civics tame, but displays Whit's skills:

 

Tuesday, October 1, 2019

4 Realities in Kentucky that have kept Democrats from Beating McConnell

Aside from the classic advantages of an incumbent and his crushing of campaign finance reform efforts, four problems endemic to Kentucky have for the last 30 years made the nationally despised Mitch McConnell unbeatable in The Bluegrass State.


1. Lousy challengers
Kentucky Secretary of State Alison Lundergan Grimes excited the nation with charisma, sharpness, and energy, as well as a small poll lead over McConnell in the early stages of the 2014 campaign. And idealistic people poured into Kentucky to join progressives here to work for her election.

What if she had accomplished the glorious victory over Senator McConnell? Well, since 2014, Lundergan Grimes – momentarily the hope of progressives -- has been accused of receiving illegal campaign money from her father, who is a longtime Democratic fundraiser; misusing data from the Secretary of State office for her partisan career ends; and riding in a state police car at 100 mph for the not-exactly emergency purpose of getting to the Kentucky Derby quickly. 

The previous Democrat challenger was Bruce Lunsford, who in the banner anti-Republican year of 2008 looked strong early against McConnell. Lunsford dripped with Kentucky credentials – he had played high school basketball, cut tobacco and owned a thoroughbred horse. But left and right soured on him as the word got around that the massive health care company Lunsford ran had been fined over alleged dumping of Medicare patients in favor of more profitable cases, and that investors in the firm had accused him of leaving them high and dry.

In the ’08 race, Lunsford had consistently maintained a small lead, but sputtered in the final weeks to a 6 percentage point loss.

In 1990, McConnell was opposed for a second Senate term by the once polished and assertive two-term Louisville mayor Harvey Sloane, a physician, Great Society veteran and Peace Corps volunteer. His lightning-like first mayoral term of 1973 to ’77 had brought the long stagnating city better mass transit, expanded minority business opportunities, EMS services, superb architectural preservation and a fine science museum.

That was then. In 1990, Senate-candidate Sloane was cited by police for open alcohol on his boat, received a letter of criticism from the AMA for the frowned-on practice of prescribing himself sleeping pills, and appeared in his own ads with a sallow face and lethargic voice.

And during a stint in the ‘80s as head of Jefferson County government (McConnell’s former position) Sloane took in campaign contributions from companies which received county contracts. Sounds more like Mitch than the solution to him.

In the 1990 Senatorial election, Harvey Sloane – who as mayor in the ‘70s had been chosen one of Time magazine’s 100 Most Influential Americans -- failed to excite the electorate and lost by eight points.

There have been other flops by McConnell opponents, but that’s enough pain.


2. Unbelievably low voter turnout

I bristled in 1975 when a high school civics textbook comparing attitudes about voting among actual Americans quoted a woman described as a waitress in a diner in Louisville saying, “I don’t have no dealings in politics.”

What an awful image for our community, but then and now, there’s no denying its authenticity – diner workers in this city 45 years ago were basically rural Kentucky transplants (today, they’re immigrants and tattooed undergrads), and looking at voter turnout numbers in the Eastern and Southern Kentucky counties denoted by the above dialect produces some shockers.
In the 2019 primary, Laurel County had an 18 percent turnout, Wayne County had a 15 percent turnout, and Casey County (the home of a recent governor, no less) had an 11 percent turnout. One county’s name may evoke the “of the people, by the people, for the people” oratory, but where were the people of Lincoln County in June 2019? – just 17 percent of them voted. Now you see why those poor counties keep going Republican; voting is overwhelmingly done by the propertied residents and unionized coal miners made scared of climate action by one-sided pundits.  

Statewide, the 2019 primary voter turnout was 19.3 percent, way up from the projected 12.5 percent. Yes, 19 percent was an unexpected surge! And 92 percent of Kentucky’s 3.4 million voter registrations are with the Democrats or Republicans, so the fact that independents can’t vote in party primaries is not a major cause of low turnout.

When the Hillary Clinton v. Bernie Sanders ’16 primary race had passions at an all-time high that produced gigantic crowds in Louisville and elsewhere, the statewide primary turnout was 20.6 percent. (Caveat: the Secretary of State website says voters who had died or moved out of state were not subtracted from the eligible numbers, so turnout may actually have been more like 25 percent, but whoop-e-de-do.)
What about general elections? In 2015, Republican Matt Bevin, a vehement right-winger, won the governorship with a general election turnout of 30 percent. His “mandate” came from 16 out of 100 registered voters.
Mitch owes the power he has amassed in the last 34 years to Kentuckians staying at home the first Tuesday of every sixth November. He has driven the GOP’s nationwide voter suppression crusade because he appreciates the weapon of non-voting.  
There have been some recent positive counter-trends. In the 2018 mid-term general election, the number of people in Louisville/Jefferson County who turned out was about 290,000; that's up from about 255,000 in the 2014 mid-terms. And that increase came in a year with no U.S. Senate race or governor’s race statewide, indicating a big anti-Trump sentiment. (UPDATE: The strongly Trump-endorsed Bevin was narrowly beaten in November 2019 by Democrat Andy Beshear in a clear rejection of Bevin's confrontational method of governing; but all other Republicans won their statewide races that election.)

3. Kentucky Democrats don’t innovate
As said, Alison Lundergan Grimes is the daughter of a well-connected political fundraiser. The 2019 Democrat governor-elect Andy Beshear is the son of the last Democratic governor Steve Beshear. The chairmanship of the state's largest Fortune 500 icon Humana Inc. was handed to David Jones Jr., son of the retiring chairman David Jones Sr. The nine-time Pulitzer wining newspaper the Louisville Courier-Journal was made journalistically great and politically influential by Barry Bingham Sr., then Barry Bingham Jr.
In a state where the right last name and where you went to high school are everything, insularity and imitativeness are bred.
A glaring absence of fresh, original spin was displayed by Grimes in 2014 in a clunky flub that turned a tied race into a sure McConnell win. 
Grimes knew that during an interview with the Louisville Courier-Journal editorial board she’d be asked if she had voted for Barack Obama – McConnell had been asked in 2008 by the paper if he had voted for a George W. Bush who in that year was deeply unpopular. (The senator answered that he had voted for W.)
Imagine Lundergan Grimes had answered this way: “Having given President Obama my vote, and being in his party, I can bargain with him for Kentucky’s interests. Mitch McConnell can’t do that. Since Mitch automatically opposes everything the administration proposes, the White House has no incentive to try to compromise with him. So, Senator McConnell cannot negotiate for our interests. But I will.”  
Instead of confidently re-framing her vote for Obama as this tool of access to benefit the state, Lundergan Grimes dived under the table. She wouldn’t say for whom she had voted in 2012 or ’08, citing the “sanctity” of the secret ballot, adding that it was her right by law to keep her vote private, and an imperative of her Secretary of State position to do so.
 Her lame attempt to appear principled, instead of enabling Lundergan Grimes to sidestep Obama’s unpopularity in a coal and tobacco state, drew cynicism and ridicule. It focused far more attention on the clash between Obama’s climate action plan and the wishes of the coal industry.  Which brings us to…

4. Coal is an emperor with no clothes
The myth that coal jobs are endangered by environmentalism isn’t challenged widely because no leader in the state’s public or private sector will open a discussion about what really took the jobs away – overreliance on coal.
Coal employment in Kentucky had already been vanishing before Obama clean air rules – in 2001, Eastern Kentucky produced 110 million tons of coal, but just about 80 million tons in 2009. The drop has been to 20 million tons in 2017, and Western Kentucky’s surface coal mines have similarly lost business.
But the plummeting numbers are due to competition from natural gas and renewables, not Obama’s clean air plan. The U.S. Energy Information Agency said that 20-million-ton yearly amount in Eastern Kentucky is expected to stay steady through 2035, with or without the Obama climate action plan.
Switching to solar and wind -- and developing cultural resources in the manner of the coal-less and booming Appalachian city of Ashville, N.C. -- could bring jobs back to rural Kentucky, but no one in Kentucky’s power structure dares talk of converting the economy. Instead, the one-note economic strategy is, bring back coal jobs.
 But they aren’t retrievable. An Appalachian Regional Commission study found: “After aggressive mining in Central Appalachia for more than a century, the remaining coal is more expensive to extract, compared to other coal-producing regions, because it tends to be deeper in the ground and/or seams tend to be thinner.”
This is why the price of electricity from Eastern Kentucky coal will no longer be competitive with natural gas, solar and wind. But an isolated and predictable state polity keeps us from hearing this.
Kentucky sorely lacks visionary state legislators, progressive labor unions, a great university, or pluralism in media. The two metro daily newspapers, the Courier-Journal and the Lexington Herald-Leader, have reported about renewables and natural gas causing coal's decline, but out there among the party leaders, chambers of commerce, and the all-powerful political fundraisers, it's as though this has never been said.
Outside of Louisville, Kentucky is as socially conservative as Mississippi, but the state as a whole has an 8 percent black population (as opposed to Mississippi’s 37 percent).
The racial differential, combined with the one-note mythmaking on coal jobs explains why since Donald Trump became president the Kentucky Republican Party has added 72,000 registered voters, to just 1,100 by the Democrats.
Democrats must challenge the coal industry’s official line, or they will continue to inflict numbers like those on themselves.

Brian Arbenz lives in Louisville, Ky. USA, the hometown of a Mitch McConnell known as - would you believe it - moderate and bi-partisan while the head of county government.